Kian-Meng Ang Weekly Review: Challenge - 014

Friday, Jul 5, 2019| Tags: Perl5, Perl6

Continues from previous post.

Feel free to submit a merge request or open a ticket if you found any issues with this post. Feedback are very much appreciated and welcome. For a quick overview, read the original questions and recap of the weekly challenge.

Challenge #1

Some participants found that it’s quite vogue to understand the Van Eck’s sequence but managed to understand it through OEIS and Numberphile’s video.

The general solution was to loop and generate the sequence but at the same time, cached the calculation (Joelle Maslak’s solution have implemented two caches).

In Rob Van Dam’s solution, he did a comparison between a cached and non-cached version. Using his solution as example, to generate 100000 sequence of numbers, the cached version took around 0.5 seconds while the non-cached ran for 9-plus minutes. Gustavo Chaves did something similar but comparing an iterative and recursive approach. Surprisingly, the recursive version even with memoization, is 33 times slow.

Some interesting stuff while reviewing this first challenge. Jaime Corchado used an unorthodox way of looping a sequence as shown below. Reading through the documentation on continue, it seemed that continue behaves like a flow control statement if it’s followed by a code block. In this case, the continue code block will be executed before the next iteration, which was used to increment the $m variable. This is similar to the finally block in the try-catch-finally constructs in some other programming languages.

    my $m = 1; # the distance between matching entries.
    for my $am (@ecks) {
        if ($an == $am) {
        $a1 = $m;
        last; # only update with most recent entry.
    } continue { $m++; }

We also noticed that more comments in the code submissions, which was quite helpful to let us know how they arrived at their solutions. Mesmerizingly, Steve Wilson’s submitted answer read like pseudocode or normal English.

Both Gustavo Chaves and E. Choroba (the only solution that used iterator and test case) have the cleanest solutions so far.

Challenge #2

Probably one of the most interesting questions of all the challenges.

Jamie Zawinski once said, “Some people, when confronted with a problem, think “I know, I’ll use regular expressions.” Now they have two problems.“. Jaime Corchado, coincidentally shares the same first name, decided to solve this challenge using a very long regex that matches every combination of the postal abbreviations. We’re not sure how he generated the regex but this was definitely a quirky approach.

Gustavo Chaves used a brilliant way to obtain the list of U.S. state codes through the Locale::US CPAN module. That approach definitely shorten the code and reduce some “noise” within the code. Also, this is a good example where a CPAN module really helps in solving the problem. And for those who are interested, please help to create a similar locale CPAN module of your country.

Again, the cleanest solution went to Neil Bowers.

use File::Slurper qw/ read_lines /;

my @states = read_lines('state-codes.txt');
my $re     = join('|', @states);
my @words  = grep { /^($re)+$/ }
             sort { length($b) <=> length($a) }

print $words[0], "\n";

Challenge #3

Out of the five participants, Rob Van Dam, and Lubos Kolouch were the newcomer to this challenge this week. Initially we thought Francis White submitted his solution (Perl 6) for the first time, little we know that he already did the challenge in week 12 but we missed it. Hence, starting from this week, for this challenge, we will look into both Perl 5 and Perl 6 solutions.

The HTTP client CPAN modules used by the participant this week were HTTP::Tiny, WWW::Mechanize, Furl, Mojo::UserAgent, and Cro::HTTP::Client (Perl 6). Only the WWW::Mechanize module which is more specialized HTTP client or a manual web browser. While we have many modules that can be used for this challenge, the Mojo::UserAgent is definitely the go-to module for modern and API related web service.

We were wondering which participant will try to emulate or simulate autocompletion at the console and Joelle Maslak did not failed us. The use of Term::Choice CPAN module for selecting different cities was a nice touch. This is one of a good reason for the third challenge. We can always discover new and interesting CPAN modules to prettify our output that fit the particular challenge. Similarly for Perl 6 solution, the Terminal::Table module was used to prettify the output.

Blog Posts

Some blog posts on this week challenge by the regular participants.

(1) Postal Words by Donald Hunter.

A write-up on the step-by-step approach to solve challenge #2.

(2) Perl Weekly Challenge 014 by Adam Russell.

Read how he solved the challenge using classic Perl idioms.

(3) Drink Coffee, Blog on Challenge 014 by Dave Jacoby.

A person who can multitask by solving the challenges while watching Last Week Tonight with John Oliver.

(4) Perl Weekly Challenge #014 by Athanasius.

A comparison of Perl 5 and Perl 6 answers as well as benchmark for for challenge #2. Surprisingly, Perl 6 solutions seemed way slower.

(5) Perl Weekly Challenge # 14: Van Eck’s Sequence and US States by Laurent Rosenfeld Another comparison of Perl 5 and Perl 6.

As usual, detailed write-up on how he solved the problem.

(6) Longest anagram of US state codes by Neil Bowers.

If you want to see the cleanest solution to challenge #2, read this. Recommendation read of the week.

(7) Hashed up Sequencing – Perl weekly challenge, week 14 by Francis Whittle.

Read how he solved the challenge while battling with Fedora installation and struggling with Cro::Http::Client module. Definitely a recommendation read of the week.

(8) Perl Weekly Challenge Week 014 by Steven Wilson.

Read his attack plans on solving both challenges.

(9) Perl Weekly Challenge 014: Van Eck and the US States by E. Choroba.

Due to the changes to challenge #2, he have created two solutions to both requirements. Learn how he use iterator to solve challenge #1. Another recommended read of the week.


If you have any suggestions or ideas then please do share with us.

Contact with me